‘I was worried her vagina was tighter than mine’: The couples giving polyamory a try for TV

While the coronavirus pandemic may have closed the world down two years ago, the government-imposed lockdown seemingly opened our minds – and our relationships.

The monotonous and arduous nature of spending days shut in with your partner has served as a catalyst in prompting new ways at looking at what we really want from a relationship; as we begin to emerge from a post-pandemic world, the quaint idea of ‘just the two of us’ no longer cuts the mustard for some.

Couples’ dating app Feeld has also demonstrated the swift and stratospheric rise of polyamory, with an increasing number of devoted partners tempted to explore open relationships involving numerous different people.

They say that search terms such as ‘ethical non-monogamy’ and ‘polyamory’ have seen an almost 400% increase among women – they were up a whopping 500% for men – in the past year. Meanwhile, six in 10 couples on the app were looking for a third person to join their relationship.

Many individuals have had the chance to think about and discuss their sexual and relationship dynamic preferences over lockdowns that has led to an increase in exploring new things,’ sex and relationships expert, Ness Cooper, tells Metro.co.uk.

‘Some may have realised that while their primary partner offers a lot of security and tick many relationship needs and wants, there’s still room for others to fulfill certain needs and wants, too.

‘It can be that some individuals have learned that it’s not their partner’s reasonability to see to every need and want within their relationship. And opening their relationship up to exploring polyamory may be a way to explore these other needs and wants without expecting one individual to fulfill them.’

Dr Loris is helping couples try ethical non-monogamy (Picture: Jonathan Ford)

Tapping into this increasing curiousity about just what an open relationship entails, is Channel 4’s brand new series Open House: The Great Sex Experiment. Billed as its ‘most shocking show ever’ (a bold claim from the home of Naked Attraction), the six part series invites poly-curious couples to explore and indulge in their fantasies in a luxury stately home, with intimacy therapist Dr Lori Beth on-hand to provide support and advice on opening your relationship in a safe and healthy way.

These couples will then be testing their relationship to see whether they’re ready for ethical non-monogamy, with their bed-shaking exploits broadcast for all to see.

Mady and Nathan decided to come on the show almost by coincidence, after a researcher for Open House slid into 25-year-old Nathan’s Instagram DMs just days after they discussed potentially becoming a thruple.

‘I’m bisexual so I’ve always considered threesomes,’ call centre worker Mady, 20, explains. ‘We’d done so much sexually, it just felt like a natural succession to bring more people into our relationship.’

The pair, based in South Wales, had been dating for a year and a half when they were approached by the show’s team – and were curious about whether they would have sex on TV.

Open House_ The Great Sex Experiment, ep1- Maddy & Nathan, looking to explore an open relationship.Mady and Nathan are interested in being a thruple (Credit: Channel 4)

‘We’d never been filmed at all ever,’ Mady says. ‘We didn’t actually know anything before we went on the show, we had no idea what it was going to be about. We went in with no expectations and we came out with so much more than we ever anticipated.

‘I got so carried away, I completely forgot the cameras were there.’

Being filmed having a threesome was less of a problem for Jess and Mike Miller. The married couple, who had been together for 10 years and share a child together (as well as Jess’ daughter from a previous relationship), earn a living by working as webcammers, with the twosome regularly indulging in sexual fantasies while eager viewers watch.

But despite their healthy sex life and their boundary-breaking career, Jess, 29, admits both herself and Mike, 31, approached the show with trepidation.

‘We’d spoken about opening up our relationship before,’ she explains. ‘We’d watched a few live streams and the idea did tickle my fancy.

‘I was like, “God, what’s the show going to be like? What are the girls going to be like, are they going to be better looking than me? Is he going to fancy them more than me?”


‘I was so nervous it was going to ruin our relationship. I was more in the mindset that it probably wasn’t going to happen. We just didn’t think there would be something we would both like.’

Jealousy was something Mady and security guard Nathan had to grapple when they considered opening their relationship.

‘I was never crazy – but it’d bother me if he was speaking to other girls,’ admits Mady.

However, when the couple did invite 37-year-old business owner Precious into their bedroom for their first ever three-way frisson, it was Nathan who struggled with jealousy.

While his initial thoughts of ‘more tits, more fun’ made the idea of a threesome more enticing, the pressure of the moment saw him unable to perform.

Open (w/t) mandyMady first struggled with jealousy (Picture: Channel 4 )

‘The pressure of the camera was still there for him, and that’s why the first go went a little bit wrong and he couldn’t keep aroused,’ says Mady. ‘You have to consider every person in a thruple. You have to consider it as an experience for all of you – the first time, I was a little bit selfish and got carried away.

‘You have to consider it’s an experience for all three people.’

Webcammer Mikey agrees that there’s far more to making polyamory work than just giving and receiving pleasure.

‘You’re having sex with your wife and another woman, it’s every straight man’s dream,’ he says. ‘Men can fantasise about having multiple partners at once, but they don’t realise you’ve got two emotional women that you have to balance out. You’ve got two women to please and communicate with, and it can be a juggling act.’

How to open your relationship safely

Sex and relationship expert Kaye Loyle from sexual wellness brand LELO UK has five steps couples should consider before attempting ethical non-monogamy.

1.       Do your research: Non-monogamy takes many shapes and forms and it’s important to have at least an initial idea of what you may or may not be interested in.

2.       Discuss it with your partner first: Talking about opening up your relationship is likely to be a discussion which is made up of multiple conversations. Don’t just expect you and your partner to be on the same page from day one – and have conversations honestly about what you are hoping to gain, what you are most worried about, most interested in, and importantly if you have any strong no’s.

3.       Establish ground rules: Often in relationships we fall into a pattern and a way of being without it ever have been an explicit conversation – if you are opening up your relationship then this may be something that you have to do so that you both know you are working on clarity of where each other is at,

4.       The first experience that you have may not be the perfect one: Expectation can often really hinder our reality of situations and we can treat these as learning experiences rather than failures.

5.       Don’t expect everyone to understand: We live in a society which is largely mononormative so you may find that people around you aren’t as on board as you would like them to be, or express their views that don’t line up with yours.

And despite being more than happy with their open relationship, Jess admits that she does still struggle with feelings of jealousy sometimes.

‘It never happens in the moment,’ she explains. ‘After our first threesome, I had to ask Mike: “Was her vagina tighter than mine?”. That’s all I wanted to know, because I had kids and she hadn’t. That was all that was going through my head. Are two vaginas the same? Does mine feel different to hers?’

It’s these sorts of concerns that arise during intimate encounters which makes regular communication with your partner(s) so important.


‘Dr Lori’s advice was so invaluable,’ Mady says. ‘She was so insightful, for her to guide us through our experiences and explaining each side of the argument clearly was vital for us.

‘You have to set clear boundaries, which can actually be quite difficult. The new challenge when you open up a relationship is setting boundaries to make it fair for both parties, and so there’s no miscommunications or feelings getting hurt.

‘This was why the opportunity to go on the show gave us was so good, as it provided us with a safe and supportive environment to experiment. We wouldn’t have been able to do this without Dr Lori.’

After six months of swinging since the filming ended, Jess and Mikey are still enjoying mixing work with pleasure, occasionally bringing a third girl into their live streams and scheduling monthly date nights where they will invite a another woman for a threesome.

The pair believe polyamory will become more mainstream, with social media platforms and shows like Open House portraying an alternative relationship structure than our monogamic norms.

‘People think it’s more acceptable to do it if they see someone else… they think, oh they’re doing it, we can do it. That’s why we did it, because we saw it online,’ Jess explains.

‘We love love. You can love two children so why couldn’t you love two partners. There’s enough love in the world you can have it shared.’

More: TV

zone post image for post 16362524

Married At First Sight's Olivia Frazer boldly claims she's 'more hated than Putin'

zone post image for post 16358620

Ricky Gervais stirs pot with alopecia joke from The Office in response to Will Smith hit

zone post image for post 16364817

Liam Payne's new twang defended by fellow accent juggler John Barrowman: 'He is who he is'

zone post image for post 16365437

Moon Knight review: Tormented Oscar Isaac is a marvel in one of MCU’s most brutal releases

Meanwhile, Mady feels she and Nathan have gotten closer since they’ve started searching for a third in their relationship.

‘It’s the weirdest thing, you wouldn’t think that sleeping with other people would make you closer to your partner, but it does,’ she says. ‘I trust Nathan so much more. I know if he sees a woman that he wants to sleep with, he can just tell me about it.

‘He may have this choice of girls but he always comes back to me, and that makes me feel quite special. I’m the one he comes back to.’

Open House: The Great Sex Experiment airs Friday 1st April at 10pm on Channel 4.

Do you have a story you’d like to share? Get in touch by emailing [email protected] 

Share your views in the comments below.

MORE : Polyamory may not be for everyone, but it’s what works for my partners and I

MORE : This Morning viewer hits back at Gino D’Acampo after he suggests having a threesome to spice up marriage: ‘Don’t be ridiculous!’

MORE : How I Do It: ‘I experimented with polyamory, but now I want monogamy’

Rush Hour Crush – love (well, lust) is all around us

Visit Metro’s Rush Hour Crush online every weekday at 4:30pm.

Tell us about your Rush Hour Crush by submitting them here, and you could see your message published on the site.

Article Categories:
Dating News